Index: [Article Count Order] [Thread]

Date:  Tue, 11 Dec 2007 02:29:45 +0000
From:  "Storer, Darren" <darren.storer (at mark) gmail.com>
Subject:  [coba-e:11393] Re: Project Live? - Updates - Disaster Recovery
To:  coba-e (at mark) bluequartz.org
Message-Id:  <1142a46a0712101829o298c2019q6da6792f4c86cda9 (at mark) mail.gmail.com>
In-Reply-To:  <200712101353.58354.bq (at mark) solarspeed.net>
References:  <683F5FB5E2C08E4A8FE8D499A890A3EA0378B7 (at mark) mainserver.mainline.local>	 <008b01c83a65$79293230$6b7b9690$ (at mark) co.uk>	 <00b601c83a6f$51871fd0$f4955f70$ (at mark) co.uk>	 <200712101353.58354.bq (at mark) solarspeed.net>
X-Mail-Count: 11393

Hi Michael,

MS > While a "do it yourself" approach is of course possible,
MS> there is also a commercial software available which does this out of the
box

please could you supply details (or a URL) for the commercial solution that
you mention above?

Many Thanks

Darren

On 10/12/2007, Michael Stauber <bq (at mark) solarspeed.net> wrote:
>
> Hi Jason,
>
> > 1. None of the Internet resource pages for BlueQuartz (Home page,
> > SourceForge, etc...) seem to be active. Is this still an active and
> > supported project and if so what Web resources have I missed?
>
> The official homepage for the BlueQuartz project is http://bluequartz.org
>
> > 2. On the BlueLinQ page only the YUM Updater works. All the other update
> > pages give: "BlueLinQ was unable to retrieve a list of packages from the
> > BlueLinQ server located at ." Presumably I am supposed to fill in the
> > relevant servers in the settings area. What should I put there or should
> I
> > in fact leave as is and forget about this facility?
>
> The only relevant menu entries in "BlueLinQ" are this:
>
> "YUM Updater": This is how you update BlueQuartz.
>
> "Installed Software": Shows installed PKGs and software components.
>
> All other menu entries are more or less deprecated and a carry over from
> the
> Sun Cobalt times when patches and updates were delivered as PKGs. They're
> just left in for historical reasons and to give third party software
> vendors
> the ability to distribute their PKGs.
>
> > 3. Now the hard question. I would like to synchronise a second
> > geographically separate server with my master for DR reasons. The second
> > server will be on a different IP address and in the case of disaster I
> > would point the relevant DNS records (not held on the master) to the
> second
> > server. However I would like it if any additions/changes to the Master
> were
> > synchronised to the secondary along with site content. Users etc... I'm
> > guessing there isn't a simple solution to this?
>
> That is something that BlueQuartz doesn't support out of the box.
>
> There are several approaches imagineable to do that and which one is best
> of
> course depends on the expected usage and how much time, efforts and money
> you
> want to invest, if you want to do it in a "do it yourself" approach, or
> want
> to buy components or entire solutions that fulfill all or most of the
> required needs. Or something in the middle.
>
> A "weak" solution would be to mirror the data through Rsync over SSH. I
> call
> it weak, because the way BlueQuartz spreads the information around on the
> disks makes it difficult to use Rsync to mirror it all. It's possible, but
> you have to have a good understanding of the architecture to make it
> happen
> without breaking things.
>
> Another approach is to use CMU to export sites and users on the primary,
> copy
> the data over to the secondary and import it there. This can be scripted
> to
> run automatically on both ends, but isn't very relieable.
>
> A better approach is to use clustering - for example with DRBD and
> Heartbeat.
> With or without virtualization. If you check the list archives you'll see
> that this has been discussed in the past. See [coba-e:05068] and
> [coba-e:08772]. While a "do it yourself" approach is of course possible,
> there is also a commercial software available which does this out of the
> box.
>
> --
> With best regards,
>
> Michael Stauber
>
>
>

	

11393_2.html (attatchment)(tag is disabled)